Tin can Tea light holder

In my quest to make only hand made gifts this Christmas, recycled when possible, I found a great tutorial on how to turn a tin can into a tea light holder (here). Here is the one I just made tonight.

Ok, so be brutally honest: is this acceptable gift material? It is meant to be for my aunt, but I'm not sure if it is good enough (I am always very critical of any of my projects, especially when it is to give away). I feel it did not come out as nicely as the one pictures in the tutorial.

Leave me a comment, I want to hear what you have to say.